| Position |
First-team
selection |
Team(s) represented
by season |
Year of
induction into
National
Baseball
Hall of Fame |
Total
votes
(First-team
votes) |
Runner-up |
Team(s) represented
by season |
Year of
induction into
National
Baseball
Hall of Fame |
Total
votes
(First-team
votes) |
| Catcher |
Johnny Bench |
Cincinnati Reds (1967–1983) |
1989 |
52 (24) |
Yogi Berra |
New York Yankees (1946–1963)
New York Mets (1965) |
1972 |
22 (4) |
| First baseman |
Lou Gehrig |
New York Yankees (1923–1939) |
1939 |
66½ (31) |
Jimmie Foxx |
Philadelphia Athletics (1925–1935)
Boston Red Sox (1936–1942[1])
Chicago Cubs (1942, 1944)
Philadelphia Phillies (1945)[2] |
1951 |
19 (3) |
| Second baseman |
Rogers Hornsby |
St. Louis Cardinals (1915–1926, 1933[3])
New York Giants (1927)
Boston Braves (1928)
Chicago Cubs (1929–1932)
St. Louis Browns (1933–1937) |
1942 |
44 (17) |
Joe Morgan |
Houston Astros (1963[4]–1971, 1980)
Cincinnati Reds (1972–1979)
San Francisco Giants (1981–1982)
Philadelphia Phillies (1983)
Oakland Athletics (1984) |
1990 |
23 (6) |
| Shortstop |
Honus Wagner |
Louisville Colonels (1897–1899)
Pittsburgh Pirates (1900–1917) |
1936 |
55 (23) |
Cal Ripken Jr. |
Baltimore Orioles (1981–2001) |
2007 |
24 (6) |
| Third baseman |
Mike Schmidt |
Philadelphia Phillies (1972–1989) |
1995 |
50 (21) |
Brooks Robinson |
Baltimore Orioles (1955–1977) |
1983 |
37 (13) |
| Left fielder |
Ted Williams |
Boston Red Sox (1939–1942, 1946–1960) |
1966 |
68 (32) |
Stan Musial |
St. Louis Cardinals (1941–1944, 1946–1963) |
1969 |
36 (4) |
| Center fielder |
Willie Mays |
San Francisco Giants (1951–1952, 1954–1972[5][6])
New York Mets (1972–1973) |
1979 |
57 (25) |
Ty Cobb |
Detroit Tigers (1905–1926)
Philadelphia Athletics (1927–1928) |
1936 |
22 (7) |
| Right fielder |
Babe Ruth |
Boston Red Sox (1914–1919)
New York Yankees (1920–1934)
Boston Braves (1935) |
1936 |
67 (31) |
Hank Aaron |
Milwaukee Braves (1954–1966
Atlanta Braves (1966–1975)
Milwaukee Brewers (1975–1976) |
1982 |
36 (5) |
| Designated hitter |
Paul Molitor |
Milwaukee Brewers (1978–1992)
Toronto Blue Jays (1993–1995)
Minnesota Twins (1996–1998) |
2004 |
48 (22) |
Harold Baines |
Chicago White Sox (1980–1989,[7] 1996–1997,[8] 2001–2002)
Texas Rangers (1989–1990[9])
Oakland Athletics (1990–1992)
Baltimore Orioles (1993–1995, 1997–1999,[10] 2000[11])
Cleveland Indians (1999) |
2019 |
12 (3) |
| Right-handed starting pitcher |
Walter Johnson |
Washington Senators (1907–1927) |
1936 |
30 (9) |
Cy Young |
Cleveland Spiders (1890–1898)
St. Louis Perfectos (1899–1900[12])
Boston Americans (1901–1908[13])
Cleveland Naps (1909–1911[14])
Boston Rustlers (1911) |
1937 |
25 (12) |
| Left-handed starting pitcher |
Sandy Koufax |
Los Angeles Dodgers (1955[15]–1966) |
1972 |
32 (11) |
Warren Spahn |
Milwaukee Braves (1942, 1946[16]–1964)
New York Mets (1965[17])
San Francisco Giants (1965) |
1973 |
28 (11) |
| Relief pitcher |
Dennis Eckersley |
Cleveland Indians (1975–1977)
Boston Red Sox (1978–1984,[18] 1998)
Chicago Cubs (1984–1986)
Oakland Athletics (1987–1995)
St. Louis Cardinals (1996–1997) |
2004 |
40 (16) |
Rollie Fingers |
Oakland Athletics (1968–1976)
San Diego Padres (1977–1980)
Milwaukee Brewers (1981–1982, 1984–1985) |
1992 |
29 (9) |
| Manager |
Casey Stengel |
Brooklyn Dodgers (1934–1936)
Boston Braves (1938–1943)
New York Yankees (1949–1960)
New York Mets (1962–1965) |
1966 |
22 (6) |
Joe McCarthy |
Chicago Cubs (1926–1930)
New York Yankees (1931–1946)
Boston Red Sox (1948–1950) |
1957 |
18 (6) |